The video was parodied in the South Park episode "Canada on Strike" where Butters performs the song in a variety of outfits. The video becomes an internet sensation, but the boys have a hard time earning any money from Butters' new-found celebrity.

Buttrolling is an internet prank, similar to Rick Rolling, whereby users divert friends to "What What (In the Butt)" through a misleading link.

• Chorus:
• I said What What In The Butt (x4)
• You want to do it in my butt, in my butt (x3)
• Let's do it in the butt, okay

• I feel you watching me over there
• Come to me if you care
• Don't sit and stare
• It's just not fair

• Make your move if you dare (what, what)

• Repeat Chorus

• It's okay if you have a little fight
• Don't you worry, I won't bite
• Not that hard if you want it, I'll give you power
• Just be gentle, I'm delicate like a flower

• Repeat Chorus

• I will give you what you need
• All I want is your big, fat seed
• Give it to me if you please
• Give it to me if you please
• Repeat once

• Repeat Chorus