• American Idol contestant Carly Smithson performed the song "Without You" on the April 15, 2008 episode of the hit televised singing competition. She played the piano.

    1. Performance date: April 15, 2008
    2. Show: American Idol
    3. Network: FOX
    4. Song: "Without You"
    5. Original artist: Badfinger
    6. Songwriters: Pete Ham, Tom Evans
    7. Original album: No Dice
    8. Original release date: November 9, 1970
    9. Notable covers: Mariah Carey
    10. Theme night: Songs by Mariah Carey

  • Judges' Comments

    1. Randy: "I liked that you challenged yourself with a big song. The power parts were cool, but you need to trust in yourself in your lower range too. Pretty good."
    2. Paula: "I actually think that that I like that you showed vocal restraint. I like that you choose different parts and made it your own."
    3. Simon: "I wanted to hear you sing this song. I don't think you pulled it off. I think you are over-thinking everything and you are wound up. It's holding you back. Believe in yourself."

Categories

American Idol