Religulous received mostly positive reviews after its screenings at the 2008 Toronto International Film Festival and the Traverse City Film Festival. Robert Koehler of Variety labeled the documentary as a "brilliant, incendiary" "[dig] at all faiths," while Kirk Honeycutt wrote in his Hollywood Reporter review that Religulous was "very, very funny."Variety: Religulous Review (August 21, 2008) The Hollywood Reporter: Religulous Review (September 4, 2008)
Negative Reviews
Reel Film Reviews' Larry Charles also thought the film was "entertaining," but felt its "repetitive nature" made it "tough to take."Reel Film Reviews: Religulous Review (2008) In a SpoutBlog review, Karina Longworth did not care for Maher's method of "using serious questioning" to "ridicule" subjects to a point of "unenlightening mockery."SpoutBlog: Religulous Review (September 6, 2008)
Possible Controversy
A reviewer for Aint It Cool News warned that Religulous "may play well" to anti-religious audiences, but may be too controversial for audiences that aren't.Ain't It Cool News: A Michigan Reader... Sees RELIGULOUS... (August 4, 2008)