The Electronic Health Record (EHR) aggregates health-related information generated across more than one healthcare organization. In contrast, the Electronic Medical Record represents information generated within a single healthcare organization. In simplest terms, the EMR is a digital equivalent of the paper chart. Despite the efforts of The National Alliance for Health Information Technology (NAHIT) and Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) to explain the differences, the terms EHR and EMR have been used synonymously.
A Personal Health Record (PHR) has similar purposes as an EHR to aggregate one's health information. However, a PHR is under the control of an individual. Electronic healthcare privacy is increasingly important as ostensibly private health information has been used by [insurance companies] and employers to deny coverage or employment.http://sites.google.com/site/hcinfosys/literature/privacy
The page provides a list of EHR functions, EHR maturity scale, and describes the numerous problems and high failure rates of EHR technology.
Usability in Health IT: Strategic, Research, and Implementation Workshop by National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) July 13, 2010
HIMSS EMR/EHR Adoption Model
HIMSS uses a seven stage EMR adoption model to determine the readiness towards EHR integration http://www.himssanalytics.org/docs/wp_emr_ehr.pdf
Stage 0: Some clinical automation may be present, but all three of the major ancillary department systems for laboratory, pharmacy, and radiology are not implemented.
Stage 1: All three of the major ancillary clinical systems are installed (i.e., pharmacy, laboratory, radiology).
Stage 2: Major ancillary clinical systems feed data to a clinical data repository (CDR) that provides physician access for retrieving and reviewing results.
Stage 3: Clinical documentation (e.g. vital signs, flow sheets) is required; nursing notes, care plan charting, and/or the electronic medication administration record (eMAR)
Stage 4: Computerized Practitioner/Physician Order Entry (CPOE) for use by any clinician is added to the nursing and CDR environment along with the second level of clinical decision support capabilities related to evidence based medicine protocols.
Stage 5: The closed loop medication administration environment is fully implemented in at least one patient care service area.
Stage 6: Full physician documentation/charting (structured templates) is implemented for at least one patient care service area.
Stage 7: The hospital has a paperless EMR environment. Clinical information can be readily shared via electronic transactions or exchange of electronic records with all entities within a regional health network.
Functions and Features of an EHR
A full-featured EHR has the following functions according to the HL7 standards http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=Product_EHR_FM:
- Identify and maintain a patient record
- Manage patient demographics
- Manage problem lists
- Manage medication lists
- Manage patient history
- Manage clinical documents and notes
- Capture external clinical documents
- Present care plans, guidelines, and protocols
- Manage guidelines, protocols and patient-specific care plans
- Generate and record patient-specific instructions
- Place patient care orders
- Order diagnostic tests
- Manage order sets
- Manage results
- Manage consents and authorizations
- Support for standard assessments
- Support for standard care plans, guidelines, protocols
- Support for drug interaction checking
- Patient specific dosing and warnings
- Support for accurate specimen collection
- Present alerts for preventive services and wellness
- Notifications and reminders for preventive services and wellness
- Support for monitoring response to notifications regarding an individual patient's health, including appropriate follow-up notifications
- Clinical task assignment and routing
- Clinical task linking
- Clinical task tracking
- Clinical task timeliness tracking
- Inter-provider communication
- Pharmacy communication
- Provider and patient or family communication
- Patient, family and care giver education
- Entity Authentication
- Entity Authorization
- Secure Data Exchange
- Enforcement of Confidentiality
- Data Retention, Availability and Destruction
- Workflow Management
- Provider demographics
- Patient demographics
- Patient's residence for the provision and administration of services
- De-identified data request management
- Scheduling
- Report generation
- Health record output
- Specialized views
- Rules-driven clinical coding assistance
- Rules-driven financial and administrative coding assistance
- Service authorizations
- Support of service requests and claims
- Claims and encounter reports for reimbursement
- Manage Practitioner/Patient relationships
There is an attempt to build certification requirements in the United States through the Department of Commerce/NIST.http://electronichealthrecordsus.net/reading-the-tea-leaves-in-a-disclosure-document-when-will-onc-and-nist-be-prepared-to-accredit-health-it-certifying-bodies/ Booz Allen Hamilton has been awarded a $400,000 contract to develop a framework for electronic health record certification.
Problems with EHR and High Failure Rates of Healthcare IT
Numerous studieshttp://sites.google.com/site/hcinfosys/literature/failure report that electronic records in healthcare are fraught with failure. An academic study in a Milbank Quarterly January 2010 article by Greenhalgh, Potts, Wong, Bark and Swinglehurst at University College London titled "Tensions and Paradoxes in Electronic Patient Record Research: A Systematic Literature Review Using the Meta-narrative Method" points this out but note that homegrown systems tended to be better received.http://eprints.ucl.ac.uk/18821/ Upwards of 80% of EMR adoptions fail especially large scale ones.http://sites.google.com/site/hcinfosys/literature/failure In Phoenix Arizona, 20% of medical practices have de-installed their EHRs due to implementation and financial reasons.http://www.mcmsonline.com/pdf/media/Pulling_EMR_Plug.pdf
A new Health Affairs article suggests $7 billion could be saved by simplifying billing - on order of projected savings of EHR it seems.http://content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/content/full/hlthaff.2009.0075v1
New Advances in EHRs
Translation of physician dictation via natural language processing into an EHR is the focus of several new products and US government research. Nuance announced some advances, acquisition, and a partnership to further the technology. The US Government is also funding the efforts for Consortium for Healthcare Informatics Research (CHIR) "to change free text as found in the doctor’s notes in electronic medical records and then translate these notes into structured data." Mr Record is an EHR that claims "data Elements imported from Physician Dictations to meet meaningful use criteria". The meaningful use criteria must be satisfied to receive a EHR benefits usage from the US Government.
Patient Privacy or Private Selling?
Unidentifiable patient data is sold to drug firms and researchers seeking patients for clinical trials.http://www.ihealthbeat.org/articles/2010/5/18/some-hospitals-share-electronic-health-data-to-earn-or-save-money.aspx
