On November 12, 2008, the National Enquirer published reports and pictures from eyewitnesses who told the magazine that McCain has been seen around Phoenix, Arizona, with another man. National Enquirer: World Exclusive: Cindy McCain Caught... (November 12, 2008) The "mystery man" was later reported to be used car salesman Dino Castelli.National Enquirer: Cindy Mccain's Secret Lover Revealed (November 20, 2008)

1. On November 12, 2008, the National Enquirer published photos of a woman who is allegedly Cindy McCain kissing another man National Enquirer: [1] (November 12, 2008)
2. Eyewitnesses told the Enquirer that McCain has been seen with another man around Phoenix, Arizona over the past several years National Enquirer: World Exclusive: Cindy McCain Caught... (November 12, 2008)
3. In July, affair said to have been with a Maryland divorce attorneyGaySocialites.com: Did Cindy McCain Have an Affair...?(June 18, 2008)
4. Cindy McCain and McCain campaign did not respond
5. No name given for supposed Maryland divorce attorney
6. John and Cindy McCain married in 1980

"Rumor on the web is that John McCain's rich wife Cindy had an affair with a Maryland divorce attorney. How do we know? Said divorce attorney is telling everyone so!"—GaySocialites.comGaySocialites.com: Did Cindy McCain Have an Affair...?(June 18, 2008)

"I couldn't believe I was watching Cindy McCain passionately kissing and hugging another man!"—"Eyewitness" in National Enquirer National Enquirer: World Exclusive: Cindy McCain Caught... (November 12, 2008)