Which Eagles quarterback is better, McNabb or Vick?

2 Answers

mahalomahalo | 1 year, 5 months ago

Vick is the better because McNabb no longer plays for the Eagles. If you mean of all time, McNabb's past was better but now Vick is the younger healthier choice. As far as talent now, Vick is more versatile and agile than Mcnabb. As far as a team player, who knows? Mcnabb in Philly was ridiculed so much it had an affect on him personally who knows about Vick. He could turn as soon as he is ridiculed. Maturity is revealed in time and so is specific stats. Both are acurate passers both are illusive in the pocket and both cause problems for defenses because of their running abilities. Right now the Redskins have Mcnabb benched so as far as performance in the future, Who knows?

You can leave an optional "tip" with Mahalo's virtual currency, Mahalo Dollars. If you are asking a difficult question that might require some research, or if you'd like a wide variety of feedback, a higher tip often leads to more answers to your question.

Report Abuse

ladylovespinstripes | 1 year, 4 months ago

McNabb has been around longer then Vick, but if Vick can win Philadelphia the city's first Superbowl ever....His status would go from good to king.

McNabb's latest stint on the Washington Redskins didn't help his career bio, but he acted like a professional much more than head Coach Mike Shanahan did.

Report Abuse

Spam (off topic & commercial)
Inappropriate (profanity, hate speech, or other violations per Terms of Service)
Plagiarism (copy and paste text without proper citations)
Illegal (fraud, phishing, violence, threats, privacy invasion, harm to minors)

Details

add an image by: URL,
Search,
Upload

Selected images:

save images cancel

add a video by URL:

Selected videos:

save videos cancel

add an audio by URL:

Selected audio:

save audio cancel

About This Question

Open until a helpful answer is received.

This question has been viewed 5 times.