I like it. I dont think its complicated at all and it seems to flow. Im no expert but i say nice job.
Permalink | Report

Ok. First rule of tumb for website design is the height of the page should not (if possible) be more than the average height of a browser window, these days that's usually around 1024x768. What this means, is to not make the user scroll down, if possible (take the Mahalo home page as ax example). Only put what fits onto one screen on the main page. On my pc, your page was 4x the height of my screen.

To save space I would limit the Walkthroughs to 1 line and the same with the Reviews. You could also limit the # of Discussions and Comments (are they the same?).

Otherwise I find the design quite good, though the orange color is a bit, umm, what's the word, harsh? it's too bright for me, but that's a matter of taste I guess.

You also seem to be missing MeTa for the search engines?

Otherwise, it looks nice and seems to work well, good luck!
Permalink | Report

I disagree with timcadieux - I think its okay for the page to be long, so long as the most important information is near the top.

I think the site looks good, except I think you should make sure you use standard web fonts, and stay consistent - I don't know what font you are using for the navigation bar, but on my screen it looks like Times New Roman (which is weird because the rest of the site and your ads are in Arial).
Permalink | Report