Not if it was here in Brazil. =/
Permalink | Report

Yes - anyone in need is your neighbor. I would certainly do what I could to help -- at the very least try to distract the assailant while calling 911.

It would be a bit difficult for me to decide whether or not to try to fight them off the victim -- if the victim isn't fighting back, it's unlikely they would return the favor if the aggressor were to start to overpower me. Probably I would look to grab some nearby instruments of pain :) in order to try and scare off the assailant, rather than risk personal injury.
Permalink | Report

To me, it's really gender based. Two women fighting, I might say something, and at most try to distract the aggressor to get her off. Two guys, honestly, I'll probably sit back and watch unless the one on the ground looks like he's gotten squishy, then comment. Female on a guy, sit back and watch. Guy on a female, jump in...if I don't think I can take him, bring my pistol.
Permalink | Report

I'm there! I'll assist anyway possible... even if it means just a simple scream... my lungs work just fine...
I could assemble a few people to help right away..

put a space between them right away... and help out with the police if nessesary.

It's important NOT to be afraid of "getting involved" THAT's LIFE -- join IN
Permalink | Report

I'd call 911 and try to stay back--getting myself killed won't help-I'm 5'2" and chrnically ill--he could knock me over with a pinky--I do carry pepper spray and would consider using it if it was taking too long for help to arrive
Permalink | Report

It just depends on the situation... whos around, who im with and whos with the person being harmed. I almost always interfere with a fight. I put distance and tell both of them to chill... if its in a restraunt please take it outside, and not disrupt the biz. if it is already outside, I let them fight.. its entertainment to me. I jus keep it safe, make sure no one is seriously hurt, and it doesnt lead into the traffic/street. If the fight continues and no one breaks it up, then I do so after I feel like it should be over... afterall i dont want a serious beating to happen... just some punchs here and there to make a point clear?

almost everything depends on the situation.

if theres jus a punk who thinks hes a bad ass picking on someone then by all means, ill accept a challenge. im physical myself.. highly active, always been into sports, I hit the gym almost every day, stretchs on the regular and am an ex muay thai fighter... so im always up for the option of defending the helpless.

=)
Permalink | Report

If I didn't think the individual had a weapon I would be much more likely to intervene in a physical manner.
There are some situations where I would be too scared to get involved though. If I am outnumbered, I won't help anything by getting involved.
Permalink | Report

If I was with a minor, I would make sure to put him/her in a safe place first. But if I was alone, I would help
Permalink | Report

I think I would help, but in reality many people wouldn't.

Oprah performed this experiment to see if people would intervene if a couple was fighting in the park.

Read about it here: http://www.oprah.com/slideshow/oprahshow/oprahshow1_ss_20080423/11

And also here:
http://oprah.about.com/od/oprahshowrecaps/p/whatwouldyoudo.htm
Permalink | Report

Absolutely. To ignore violence is to condone it if you are able-bodied enough to intervene.
Permalink | Report

In the 1980s there was a man who severely beat his wife outside of his house. The neighbors - many of them - watched as he stomped, kicked, and otherwise battered her while they ignored her pleas for help. No one done a thing.

There was a "made for tv" movie based on the event as well.

After this, psychologists really wanted to know why this happened. Why didn't anyone do anything? Their studies found that the more people there are, the more likely everyone is going to assume that someone else is going to do something. This results in everyone doing nothing.

Hopefully I can respond soon with some sources, but I should be studying for finals tomorrow.. someone else is encouraged to respond with sources before I do.

The bottom line is that although most people would like to believe that they would do something, most people would not.

I'm a psychology major and I'm aware of the social behavior in this setting. Being aware of this would help me think beyond the normal response. Knowing me, I would immediately call 911 and I would describe the situation to the officers to ensure that the assailant went to jail.

Worse comes to worse I do have some martial arts training. Don't take that the wrong way. I am no "tough guy". I would avoid any physical confrontation if at all possible. I've done open sparring before though, and I've been hit hard enough to get a cracked rib. Psychologically and physically I've already been there to some degree and could probably react better than, say, a woman who's getting beat on by her boyfriend or husband.

This is not what I would want to do though. For both legal reasons as well as reasons of personal safety I would prefer to let the officers to take care of the situation.
Permalink | Report

I'd probably call 911, but wouldn't physically intervene myself.
Permalink | Report

Most definitely. I have in the past although it's scary, I find it to be always the right choice.
Permalink | Report

I'd like to think so, yes.
Permalink | Report

You have to remember in many States at least in the US the first one that files a police report is the one who wins because police will charge the other person involved.

That means while stepping in that you have a friend call the police using a cell phone and that friend be ready to file the police report.
Permalink | Report

That's a tricky question, what is your definition of taking action? If you get involved you can be held liable for your actions. For example, if you were to use force on someone to stop an assault. You also run the risk of putting yourself in danger in that scenario.
Permalink | Report

I would call 9-1-1 first and while the police were on their way, i'd try to step in and break it up
Permalink | Report

I would take a picture with my camera phone, call 911, and probably yell something from a safe distance and behind a tree if I could find one.
Permalink | Report

That depends on whether or not the two people know each other.
Permalink | Report

Absolutely. However, it is a lot more thorny issue than most suppose, because any action on your part may lead to both parties charging you with an assault. My actions would be limited to providing defense of the weaker party, or, with the aid of some other similarly-minded bruiser (I'm 6'3", 270#), pull the combatants apart.

If either of the combatants is sufficiently larger than his/her victim, I'd probably be perfectly ok with actually going on the offensive to subdue the larger combatant, but then, I'd be preventing a possible maiming or murder.

Before anyone takes any action, they should consider both the legal ramifications and the possibility of injury. I would recommend not getting involved unless you know how to handle yourself and know the situation actually presents a risk of serious injury.
Permalink | Report

In today's world I hate to say it but no, I would not get in the middle of it. To many people carrying weapons these days. If there was violence involved then i would call the cops. But i would call from the comfort of my home and keep my nose out of it.

Now if a child was involved then that is a whole other story!
Permalink | Report

Definately!
Permalink | Report

Yes I will call 911. Try to offer help. But I may not put my life in danger protecting the one being attacked.
Permalink | Report

Me, myself, i would have to. Being served in the military and staying true to the law and all its practices, the Good Samaritan law provides i must take action.
Permalink | Report

I would try to intervene unless it posed a life-threatening danger to myself. If I couldn't help out physically, I would definitely call the police and try to get others around to help me with the situation. I think as a human being, it is our instinct to help each other out. If it were me being beat down, I sure would want someone to help me out. It's the Golden Rule.
Permalink | Report

Yes absolutely. And without hesitation. Not only that but with my current line of profession it would be my duty to intervene.

Defending those who cannot defend themselves has been my lifes work.

And i don't care if you are 5 feet taller than me and are armed and dangerous. I'll take it to you .

Ofcoars calling the authorities would probably be the best thing to do first seeing you are of no use to the person if you are blind, bleeding, dieing or dead already.
Permalink | Report

yes, if I was in danger a phone call if I felt I could help otherwise I'd step in
Permalink | Report