This is interesting... I would tend towards giving people a tip for good questions. I'd like to find a way to encourage people to write good, clear questions instead of the crap I've been seeing.

I REALLY want to help and answer questions, but some of these confusing questions are really starting to frustrate me.
Permalink | Report

I have to agree with the consensus thus far. While this would increase traffic by a little bit, it would degrade quality by a lot.

There are already countless questions where the people asking them have only a rudimentary grasp of the English language (and saying that is generous); just imagine how many terribly worded and ambiguous questions users would have to sift through if Mahalo started giving away money for asking questions in addition to answering them. In short, I think it'd start turning Mahalo into something akin to Yahoo! Answers.

Look at the linked question for a good example of what would happen were Mahalo to implement rewards for simply asking questions.

I think if one were to go about giving money for questions, it should be based on the number of users who click on it as interesting. But even then, as the community grew and got larger, you'd have people who would be gaming the system.
Source(s):
http://www.mahalo.com/answers/cars-trucks/what-happened-to-the-freedom-in-t...

Permalink | Report

I think that if everyone were to get paid for questions - wouldn't people just ask question rather than answer them.

I think it would also ruin the dedication of the Answering committee. People that are new will likely ask tons of questions rather than answers and get tips. Some members may be willing to answer - but the questions will be likely to be poor if they got paid.

Instead, something along the lines of a question that is by Mahalo standards interesting could gain a $1 and be pinned to the top of the tipped/non-tipped question.
Permalink | Report