Next Question
Email to a friend |
RSS
No Best Answer Selected, Tip Refunded
Also, congratulations to @Arjo, @Demanda and everyone else. Even if you only completed one page, you're M$2 richer and there ain't nuthin' wrong with that.
I'm currently saving my Mahalo dollars so that I can attend to the Techcrunch50 in September. This helps out a lot! It was fun to compete and I liked the whole barnraising spin that engaged the spirt of the community.
Here are my notes on the contest. I've gone to the effort to write them down in the hope that other Mahalo members might find a couple of the points helpful.
1)
Before this contest was announced live last week, I had already decided that I was going to work hard at it. I knew that I wouldn't be able to devote my regular working hours to the tasks, but I know that when I "slip into overdrive" that I can bust out a ton of work.
2)
I was shocked at how quickly tasks were approved. Before I submitted my first block of pages, I figured the delay between submission and approval would be the biggest problem with the contest. I was wrong. On Sunday (of all days), I submitted a few tasks and had them accepted immediately. This was really great and if this continues through the next contest, it will mean that anyone from a newbie to a blackbelt really can win the next contest.
3)
I really appreciated the feedback that I received each time a task was accepted. There isn't any feedback when a Mahalo SERP is created or updated and I think that this omission is a problem. While completing these tasks, I received some helpful feedback from the staff that quickly allowed me to improve. Even when I hit my stride, the Mahalo staff took the time to write quick comments of encouragement. I found that motivating and think that feedback and community participation is the problem with the current Mahalo SERP process / model.
4)
Technically, I only encountered two problems. This was the first Barnraising contest and I expected a few technical glitches. I was again wrong and was able to fly through the site and process. Kudos and thanks to the Dev's. My first technical problem occurred on Wednesday but was noticed by @Danielle before I could report it! Even after the problem was solved, my page claim limit was handicapped from 10 down to 8, but that didn't cause a problem for me. My second glitch occurred in the final stretch of the competition. I claimed Ovguide.com and Foxnews.com but somehow lost claim on both of those pages.
5)
Some stats:
I completed 43 pages.
I would have completed more pages if I could have freed up more time. Work however interfered with the contest. When Lon released the first leaderboard, I did some math and figured out that it would take me 46 pages to win. The submission rate that I calculated was wrong because @Arjo slowed down. But I didn't care; I kept plugging away at the pages trying to reach my 46 page goal.
None of my pages were rejected. However, I was given some great feedback on my first few to correct some early mistakes.
On average, pages took me 16.43 minuets each to complete.
Yes, I am a nerd and timed each one so that I could get faster.
My fastest page (Adbrite) was completed in 7 minuets.
I spent 11 hours of my free time completing tasks over the course of 7 days.
I made M$86 in tips plus I won M$200 for a total of M$286.
6)
If you want to see exactly how I completed pages, here is a screencast that I made with some commentary, tips and my entire workflow:
http://www.screencast.com/t/7gl0a6gpaKE
So... my advice... get into the next contest, come in first, win the big prize and beat my 43 page record if you can :)
Do me a solid and follow me on Twitter - I love hearing what Mahalo folks are up to when they're not kickin' here.
http://twitter.com/RobIsIT
Helpful Answer?
(11)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
christhoms...
I'm starting on the 2nd one though lol
I'm saving up my mahalo dollars for my kids school supplies (I have 5!!)
so anyway again, way to go everyone!!! and congratulations to the top three, I bow to your awesomeness :)
Permalink | Report
Question
M$10
July 14, 2009 01:30 AM
Barnraising Contest #1: It's over! Here are the winners!
Our first barnraising Mahalo Tasks contest is complete! Together, you guys created 250 quality Mahalo pages for an area in which we really needed to expand our coverage.
First of all, THANKS! We really appreciated everyone's participation and enthusiasm. The next barnraising, which will be about movies, starts tomorrow morning, and the first tasks are already going up. Start claiming them and working on them as soon as you can, and we'll start approving them first thing tomorrow.
And now on to the winners!
1ST PLACE (M$200): @Robbrown, 43 Tasks
2ND PLACE (M$100): @Arjo, 30 Tasks
3RD PLACE (M$50): @Demanda, 28 Tasks
Congrats to the winners. Great job to everyone who got tasks accepted. Your names and totals are listed below...
20 Tasks
----------
@Christhomson
17 Tasks
----------
@Pawsalmighty
16 Tasks
----------
@Jdnyc
11 Tasks
----------
@The_unix_geek
9 Tasks
----------
@Jkepler, @Blitzkreig
7 Tasks
----------
@N4thanl, @Zesi
6 Tasks
----------
@Gno
5 Tasks
----------
@Mahaloguru, @Krysstel
4 Tasks
----------
@Greenfreelancer, @Pellrider
3 Tasks
----------
@M2master, @Krusheasy
2 Tasks
----------
@Howulikethemapples, @Socalsue, @Thebandit, @Badaspie, @Sukmrsing
1 Task
----------
@Interzone, @Nicolac, @Jeska2481, @Wook, @Jonbowen234, @Tgood1, @Rogeniobelem, @Psynopsis
http://z.about.com/d/honeymoons/1/0/1/r/05amish_barnraising.jpg
First of all, THANKS! We really appreciated everyone's participation and enthusiasm. The next barnraising, which will be about movies, starts tomorrow morning, and the first tasks are already going up. Start claiming them and working on them as soon as you can, and we'll start approving them first thing tomorrow.
And now on to the winners!
1ST PLACE (M$200): @Robbrown, 43 Tasks
2ND PLACE (M$100): @Arjo, 30 Tasks
3RD PLACE (M$50): @Demanda, 28 Tasks
Congrats to the winners. Great job to everyone who got tasks accepted. Your names and totals are listed below...
20 Tasks
----------
@Christhomson
17 Tasks
----------
@Pawsalmighty
16 Tasks
----------
@Jdnyc
11 Tasks
----------
@The_unix_geek
9 Tasks
----------
@Jkepler, @Blitzkreig
7 Tasks
----------
@N4thanl, @Zesi
6 Tasks
----------
@Gno
5 Tasks
----------
@Mahaloguru, @Krysstel
4 Tasks
----------
@Greenfreelancer, @Pellrider
3 Tasks
----------
@M2master, @Krusheasy
2 Tasks
----------
@Howulikethemapples, @Socalsue, @Thebandit, @Badaspie, @Sukmrsing
1 Task
----------
@Interzone, @Nicolac, @Jeska2481, @Wook, @Jonbowen234, @Tgood1, @Rogeniobelem, @Psynopsis
http://z.about.com/d/honeymoons/1/0/1/r/05amish_barnraising.jpg
Interesting Question?
Yes (16)
No (0)
Interesting: jeffhoard, kalane, eculver, lauriem, danielle, matthewh, robbrown, ericc, lesliec, easyeboy, jasoncalacanis, valz, bunnyphuphu, rslakinski, interzone, sysaaron
- In Mahalo Answers Community |
- |
- Report |
-
Share
RSS
No Best Answer Selected, Tip Refunded
Answers (8)
July 14, 2009 02:19 AM
Whoo Hoo!!! Thank-you very much!!!!! Also, congratulations to @Arjo, @Demanda and everyone else. Even if you only completed one page, you're M$2 richer and there ain't nuthin' wrong with that.
I'm currently saving my Mahalo dollars so that I can attend to the Techcrunch50 in September. This helps out a lot! It was fun to compete and I liked the whole barnraising spin that engaged the spirt of the community.
Here are my notes on the contest. I've gone to the effort to write them down in the hope that other Mahalo members might find a couple of the points helpful.
1)
Before this contest was announced live last week, I had already decided that I was going to work hard at it. I knew that I wouldn't be able to devote my regular working hours to the tasks, but I know that when I "slip into overdrive" that I can bust out a ton of work.
2)
I was shocked at how quickly tasks were approved. Before I submitted my first block of pages, I figured the delay between submission and approval would be the biggest problem with the contest. I was wrong. On Sunday (of all days), I submitted a few tasks and had them accepted immediately. This was really great and if this continues through the next contest, it will mean that anyone from a newbie to a blackbelt really can win the next contest.
3)
I really appreciated the feedback that I received each time a task was accepted. There isn't any feedback when a Mahalo SERP is created or updated and I think that this omission is a problem. While completing these tasks, I received some helpful feedback from the staff that quickly allowed me to improve. Even when I hit my stride, the Mahalo staff took the time to write quick comments of encouragement. I found that motivating and think that feedback and community participation is the problem with the current Mahalo SERP process / model.
4)
Technically, I only encountered two problems. This was the first Barnraising contest and I expected a few technical glitches. I was again wrong and was able to fly through the site and process. Kudos and thanks to the Dev's. My first technical problem occurred on Wednesday but was noticed by @Danielle before I could report it! Even after the problem was solved, my page claim limit was handicapped from 10 down to 8, but that didn't cause a problem for me. My second glitch occurred in the final stretch of the competition. I claimed Ovguide.com and Foxnews.com but somehow lost claim on both of those pages.
5)
Some stats:
I completed 43 pages.
I would have completed more pages if I could have freed up more time. Work however interfered with the contest. When Lon released the first leaderboard, I did some math and figured out that it would take me 46 pages to win. The submission rate that I calculated was wrong because @Arjo slowed down. But I didn't care; I kept plugging away at the pages trying to reach my 46 page goal.
None of my pages were rejected. However, I was given some great feedback on my first few to correct some early mistakes.
On average, pages took me 16.43 minuets each to complete.
Yes, I am a nerd and timed each one so that I could get faster.
My fastest page (Adbrite) was completed in 7 minuets.
I spent 11 hours of my free time completing tasks over the course of 7 days.
I made M$86 in tips plus I won M$200 for a total of M$286.
6)
If you want to see exactly how I completed pages, here is a screencast that I made with some commentary, tips and my entire workflow:
http://www.screencast.com/t/7gl0a6gpaKE
So... my advice... get into the next contest, come in first, win the big prize and beat my 43 page record if you can :)
Do me a solid and follow me on Twitter - I love hearing what Mahalo folks are up to when they're not kickin' here.
http://twitter.com/RobIsIT
Helpful Answer?
(11)
(0)
Helpful: dbiddie, christhomson, easyeboy, jasoncalacanis, brian san, spoon, greenfreelancer, eculver, hillo, nyssa, interzone
Tip robbrown for this answer
christhoms...
July 14, 2009 02:52 AM
Great video, Rob! Congrats on winning!
Tip christhomson for this comment
Report
July 14, 2009 05:53 AM
Rob, That video was very helpful ... nicely done. Helps us devs to get a feel for what is going through a user's head ... also, tip of the cap for use of Wayback Machine :) nicely done.
Report
July 14, 2009 11:10 AM
Way to go everyone! I didn't get started on this until late, because I didn't know about it and was really new to the place, so I'm pretty happy with how I did. I'm starting on the 2nd one though lol
I'm saving up my mahalo dollars for my kids school supplies (I have 5!!)
so anyway again, way to go everyone!!! and congratulations to the top three, I bow to your awesomeness :)
Permalink | Report
Answer this Question
Related Questions
No questions found.
Ask a Question
Buy Mahalo Dollars with Credit Card or PayPal
Top Members
Most Popular Tags
Categories
- Anonymous
- Arts & Design
- Beauty & Style
- Books & Authors
- Business
- Cars & Transportation
- Consumer Electronics
- Coupons Deals
- Education
- Entertainment
- Environment
- Fitness
- Food & Drink
- From Email
- From Iphone
- From Twitter
- Health
- History
- Hobbies
- Home & Garden
- How Tos
- Humor
- Jobs
- Legal
- Local
- Love & Relationships
- Mahalo Answers Community
- Money
- Music
- News
- NSFW
- Parenting
- Pets
- Science & Mathematics
- Services
- Shopping
- Social Science
- Society & Culture
- Sports
- Technology & Internet
- Travel
- Video Games
Welcome New Members
- norah01, November 29, 2009 01:20 AM
- muna2255, November 29, 2009 01:19 AM
- andeta, November 29, 2009 01:14 AM
- samhubbard, November 29, 2009 01:12 AM
- 31653527, November 29, 2009 01:09 AM
Mahalo Dollars are the currency of Mahalo Answers.
Each Mahalo Dollar costs $1.
Once you earn more than 40 Mahalo Dollars, you can request to be paid via PayPal. Each Mahalo Dollar is currently worth $0.75 when paid out via PayPal. Learn More
