Next Question
RSS
Ok, here we go ...
I actually found this to be a very strong finale that turned the series upside down. It has blown my mind that the whole "war that is coming" has had nothing to do with Linus vs. Widmore. All a red herring! Jacob said it himself, "What about you?". Those two are insignificant children fighting over the same toy and have no major role in the real war.
So here is my theory:
Jacob and his mystery nemesis (let's call him...Killer) are gods. Maybe not the exact Egyptian gods that are being fawned over by fanboys right now, but something parallel and similar to those.
Jacob and Killer are at odds - good vs. evil (though who is good? Still unsure.), and Jacob seems to have the upper ground right now. My early theory is that it's because he's taken on this corporeal form that allows him to work with mortals and have great influence in the outer world beyond the Island.
But Killer....I think he's stuck in non-corporeal form. In fact....GET READY FOR THIS....I think HE'S the smoke monster! And I think he requires dead bodies to take on the image of the deceased - hence the whispers, hence the appearance of Claire, Christian, Boone, etc. all after their deaths. I think Killer has been looking to manifest himself for a looong time to overpower Jacob.
And as part of some kind of set of godly rules, Killer cannot murder his parallel god, Jacob. So he manifests himself as Locke to persuade Ben to do it for him. Oh, and you know that ash surrounding "Jacob's cabin"?, I bet that was to keep Killer at bay. Maybe...still unsure about the details there with the cabin.
Furthermore, I think that Killer is some kind of god of death - hence why the "Smoke Monster" judges people for their actions in this life, takes the lives of some, and hence why he can invoke the images of the dead! So what kind of god does that make Jacob? So far by his opening comments it just seems like he likes "progress" and chaos.
And the Losties? I think they've been caught up in a giant game of chess as the two gods try to assert their power and influence over the group for their own pleasure and ends.
The "Hostiles"? I think - much like this new group toting Locke's body - they're devotees to the Jacob god. But then, does anybody worship and serve Killer? Hmmm....to every yin there is a yang.
Back in 1977 I think it's pretty clear that our Losties caused the "Incident", as they were always meant to. And I assume that is what will vault them into modern day...but I'm guessing they'll still be on the Island with nothing erased. I'm just wondering if Dr. Chang will be transported with him as the electromagnetism vaults them through time. If not, then how on earth does he survive a nuclear blast?
Soooo many questions, sooo many months until the next season. Superb finale. A+++ all the way!
Helpful Answer?
(8)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Jacob = Sobek (check the alligator head and this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobek)
Richard Alpert = Ra
Horace Goodspeed = Horus
Locke = ? Going to guess Osiris
Sobek, Ra and Horus also seem to have a lot of dealings in Egyptian mythos, so they seem to 'fit' well together.
Beyond that ... not sure.
I wasn't happy with it. Not a lot happened for two hours except a few hippie gunfights (again). This season has been really strong, so the weak finale was a surprise -- I expected more.
Source(s):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobek
Tags: sobek, horus, lost
Helpful Answer?
(3)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
What really surprises me about this series is how Josh Holloway and Terry Quinn have stolen the show. I thought that the characters of Jack and Kate would carry this show, but it is Sawyer and Locke who have captivated me, and Holloways performance in this episode was incredible.
Sawyer for all his toughness is, in reality, at the mercy of the the others around him. You see this in the expression of bewilderment on his face at the actions of Jack, Kate and Juliet. He is buffeted by their changing attitudes and plans. Although he teases Hugo, he actually feels more at ease in the company of the big guy.
For Sawyer, destiny is a lot less comfortable than normalcy.
The real mystery is John Locke. The man that looks like John Locke appears to be the man that was on the island at the beginning with Jacob.
And so we have wheels within wheels. The conflict between Ben and Charles Widmore is secondary to the real conflict between Jacob and the other guy.
Permalink | Report
The Island has long been a character in and of itself. In many cultures, the Earth itself is envisioned as an island (sometimes on the back of a turtle, or another creature).
In ancient Egypt, Nit (Nieth) was the creator of all life, and the protector of Pharoah, Ra, and the god/ddess (s/he was androngenous) to whom the other gods came when they could not settle their disputes. She also guarded the coffin and associated canopic jars of one of the sons of Horus. S/he was the patron goddess of both war--and weaving. I am looking at her hieroglyphs for her name, and I think they may have been either on the wall in the underground area where the bomb was, or was on Jacob's weaving.
Isn't this what he was making?
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bd/Egypt.Papyrus.01.jpg
That would be Anubis.
Ammit is another crocodile-headed god, whose job it was to judge the hearts of the dead. She was known as Devourer of Souls, but her function was to destroy evil. She was the guardian of the lake of fire. I'm thinking she's the smoke thing. I don't mean "Ammit is the smoke thing", but that somehow we'll find out that this is all Egyptian legend become real.
How that could happen is this: we know the Island can become shaken free of time and space. Perhaps at one time in the past, the island was in the Mediterranean, or off the coast of the Arabian Peninsula in the Arabian Sea.
According to Egyptian myth, at one point Osiris was killed and washed up on the banks of the Nile. What if he washed up on the banks of the Island instead?
According to the myth, then he was reanimated as Lord of the Dead.
I think Richard is Osiris in some way. Osiris was called "Ever Youthful", which we've noticed about Jacob; but it applies to both of them.
Then the rest makes sense: Horus, his son, was charged with protecting the people from Set, who killed Osiris and is thus both his enemy and Horus'. Set, incidentally, was Osiris' older brother, and the god of storms, darkness, and *necessary* chaos.
Horus would be Jacob. The legend also says that sometimes he would fail to recognize friends and mistake them for enemies, during the dark phase of the moon.
In the legend, Set and Horus had battles for years, so maybe I've got Osiris and Horus switched. But from last night's episode (the final episode of the season) this is a battle that's been raging for centuries, and this might finally be the last one.
There's an interesting little story about keeping a body in a box, too, when Set either tricked or put Osiris into a lead box that became his coffin. Only according to last night's episode and my reading of this, that would have been Set in the box.
Daniel Faraday's mother could possibly be Nephthys, sister/wife of Set, whose role it was to both guard Horus, and a very important role that included "gathering and mourning"--a mystical cycle crucial to the balance of chaos and order. She ages, though. So I'm not sure about this one, but it's a good parallel. Together with Juliet, they accomplished this season's goal. In the legend, it was Isis and Nephthys together who did the gathering and mourning.
So I think the background myth is from the whole Egyptian Underworld myth, and doesn't have much to do with other Egyptian gods like Ra.
I don't think that it's a straight retelling of the Egyptian religious myths, but a story that focuses on one of them and then brings other things in. Juliet, for example, has a lot in common with Isis. But she's not Isis: we know her parents divorced when she was around 10; that her sister had trouble conceiving. She ages. Daniel Faraday's mother ages.
So, I guess the series could be construed as: Part of the Egyptian pantheon were real (the ones associated with death). They are on a time-traveling island that appears on no charts. They handpick people to prove their respective points of good over evil/evil over good. The Oceanic Flight were hand-picked for the final battle, and it appears some of them were in the process of squaring off against each other. Only pairs of opposites like Bernard and Rose find peace; Kate/Jack/Sawyer/Juliet need to figure out which of them are going to pair off to find their place in the battle. Looks like they did in this episode; or maybe they got it wrong and that's why Juliet ended up at the bottom of the unbuilt hatch.
Next season? "They're coming" might refer to everyone coming back to life because the hatch was never built; it might refer to others in the Pantheon coming back to settle things. Hard to say.
Source(s):
http://www.touregypt.net/featurestories/nit.htm
http://ablemedia.com/ctcweb/consortium/ancientegyptiangodsneith.html
http://www.ancientegyptonline.co.uk/thegods.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duat
Tags: ancientegypt, lost, theories
Helpful Answer?
(2)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
A "magician" of sorts, trapped on an island in exile, uses his powers to "call" on a ship. The castaways are then divided up into groups. Plots to overthrow Prospero are devised and abandoned, various other subplots are raised and thwarted, but all the time, Prospero is quiety influencing the main action and drawing the characters closer to him.
Similarly, "Jacob" is stranded on this island and manipulating those who pass through, though he's also locked in something of a rivalry with another god-like creature there.
Each season on "Lost" has set up this sort of binary conflict. We always think we're figuring out what the REAL rivalry is that's going on, only to find that it's more complex and mysterious than we thought...
Castaways vs. each other (Season 1)
Castaways vs. castaways from other side of the plane (Season 2)
Castaways vs. The Others (Season 3)
The Others vs. Dharma/Ben vs. Widmore (Season 4)
Jacob vs. Other God-like Being (Season 5)
My guess is Season 6 will continue this pattern...
Possibly:
Castaways vs. Other God-like Being (who's currently in possession of Locke's body, and probably has the ability to invade other dead people's bodies as well)
All the mention of some dark force that's "coming" could also be the final rivalry that we'll see play out, and even this playful back-and-forth among the gods is not the REAL FIGHT that's been playing out all this time. Perhaps Jacob and his rival are merely jockeying for position in preparation for some EVEN LARGER and more dangerous adversary that's still unknown to viewers.
Permalink | Report
When it comes to the origin of the electromagnetic energy, the context of much of the context of Jacob's conversation with the other guy in the flashback, as well as Richard Alpert's long life and familiarity (though not by sight) with those folks who brought the crate with Locke's body to him....
Seems to me the explanation that makes the most sense is that a group of extraterrestrials crashed a very long time ago and there is no longer any surface indication of their craft on the island. That they're ship included a "black smoke" security system that attacks those of unclear motives who get too close to the ship or are potentially in conflict with the ETs.
Indigenous people's built temple's and worshiped them while the ETs have continuously brought groups of other humans to the island to demonstrate their "worthiness" and ability to exercise their choice and free will ...and this goes towards the ET's purpose.
There is a faction within the ETs that does not believe in human's potential and is tasked with exposing this weakness.
The extraterrestrial's, while very powerful and beyond human abilities, are not gods but able to inhabit human forms for their purposes, extending those human form's lives indefinitely, and or granting other humans healing or other abilities.
The extraterrestrials include Richard Alpert, Jacob, the other guy he was speaking with in the flashback, and likely all those who recently arrived carrying Locke's cargo crate to show Richard.
The Dharma construction breached a reactor of some sort, and the large Wheel that Ben turned was some part of a control to manage a time dilation field inherent in the ship's construction.
AND, the detonation of a nuclear device may not reset the time line of events as Faraday and Jack believe....depending on what fuels the drive for the extraterrestrial craft...anti matter? some much heavier radioactive isotope? a nuclear detonation may do a number of things including further scramble events and time lines, obliterate the planet, or provide the extraterrestrials with the evidence of human free will they may have been seeking provoking the arrival of a mothership for their return or to retrieve those few humans responsible for a greater mission.
Permalink | Report
I love what they did with Jacob, integrating him into the characters back stories, but I'm still wondering why he was there. Some had a point, like his meeting with Hurley, but others, like his meeting with Jack seemed insignificant.
I was shocked to fin out Locke was actually dead ever since Ben killed him. And it looks like the new Ben was that other guy in the form of a shape shifter. At least that's what I gathered. Ahh, now I gotta go back an rewatch it from that perspective.
I like that they answered a lot of questions, but like always, that bring up many more questions. So Jacob can live long like Richard and cannot be killed by that other guy, but Ben can kill him with a knife? I thought that was odd.
And now it looks like Juliet just detonated the H Bomb. Who know what kind of effect that will have.
Overall, awesome finale. The producers, writers, and actors of this show are amazing. Can't wait til next season!
Permalink | Report
Black vs white. Good vs Evil. Faith vs Science. We continue to get this play of opposing forces throughout the story. Two mysterious men (Jacob and "Esau") - dressed in black and white discuss what sounds like some cosmic battle, some pattern, some endless loop they've been playing out through the ages. Are they demigods? Fallen angles? Or are they ordinary men - somehow caught up and displaced from the normal flow of time, space and physical laws by the island - doomed to relive a gruesome series of wars and battles that take place throughout the ages over control of the island? Could they have been soldiers or researchers from the US Army mission that once visited the island? They certainly seem to have some modern sensibilities despite their appearance hundreds of years ago watching as the Black Rock comes to the island.
The men speak of the endless violence - everyone comes to the island to kill one another and fight for control, and it always ends the same. But in the finale we are presented with an alternative - Rose and Bernard. They have simply chosen to live in peace and harmony. And they have been allowed to do so. Rose and Bernard are appearing more and more like the "Adam and Eve" found in the cave in season 1. Perhaps they are the only ones who come to realize that the island need not be a place of fear and death - it can be Eden - it is a matter of ones own choosing.
But the two men, they cannot seem to find peace. Must one of them die in order to break the holding pattern they find themselves in? We know that Jacob can leave the island, but can he ever be free of it? Is he like Jack, doomed and compelled to always return? And now that Jacob appears dead - now that the closing title has flipped from white on black to black on white - the power of the island has changed hands? Jacob, who we were lead to believe was the malevolent force, was depicted as a compassionate figure in this episode - weaving his way through the lives of the Losties - tugging at the threads like those in a loom in order to create a new pattern as he worked to help each one of them
Now that Jacob appears slain by the real force that has haunted the Losties from day one. The question is, who are "they" and how will they stop him?
Permalink | Report
Permalink | Report
From the argument that Jacob and Esau are having at the beginning of the episode, it appears that Jacob keeps bringing people to the island to try and work something out. Bringing the Black Rock to the island was just one moment in a long history. Esau believes it will never work and is looking for a loophole to kill Jacob.
Now we see Jacob interacting with the Losties before they ever come to the island. He is careful to touch each one of them and must be selecting them to come somehow.
Esau has been looking for his loophole and he has found it by taking on the appearance of dead people in order to manipulate those on the island. Jack's father, Christian, and now Locke. Richard thinks that "Esau in the guise of Locke" is the real leader, but actually that role has fallen back on Ben after the real Locke's death.
When they approach the statue, Richard complains that only the leader can come into Jacob's home, thinking that only Esau/Locke can come in. But Ben is the leader again and he is able to come in. Esau/Locke has manipulated Ben, the leader of the Others, to want to kill Jacob. This is the loophole - Ben doesn't realize that he is the real "Leader" and comes in to see Jacob because the rules allow him too and then stabs Jacob in an attempt to kill him.
Somehow, I think that despite the loophole that Esau has found, Jacob will not die from Ben's stabbing.
Permalink | Report
Answered Question
M$1
May 14, 2009 07:16 AM
LOST season finale theories/recap
Interesting Question?
Yes (7)
No (0)
Interesting: marcand, gno, rslakinski, soundboy, lon, jeffhoard, cynthiag
- In Lost TV Show |
- Tags: seasonfinale, lost |
- |
- Report |
-
Share
RSS
Best Answer Decided by Votes
| May 14, 2009 02:33 PM |
I actually found this to be a very strong finale that turned the series upside down. It has blown my mind that the whole "war that is coming" has had nothing to do with Linus vs. Widmore. All a red herring! Jacob said it himself, "What about you?". Those two are insignificant children fighting over the same toy and have no major role in the real war.
So here is my theory:
Jacob and his mystery nemesis (let's call him...Killer) are gods. Maybe not the exact Egyptian gods that are being fawned over by fanboys right now, but something parallel and similar to those.
Jacob and Killer are at odds - good vs. evil (though who is good? Still unsure.), and Jacob seems to have the upper ground right now. My early theory is that it's because he's taken on this corporeal form that allows him to work with mortals and have great influence in the outer world beyond the Island.
But Killer....I think he's stuck in non-corporeal form. In fact....GET READY FOR THIS....I think HE'S the smoke monster! And I think he requires dead bodies to take on the image of the deceased - hence the whispers, hence the appearance of Claire, Christian, Boone, etc. all after their deaths. I think Killer has been looking to manifest himself for a looong time to overpower Jacob.
And as part of some kind of set of godly rules, Killer cannot murder his parallel god, Jacob. So he manifests himself as Locke to persuade Ben to do it for him. Oh, and you know that ash surrounding "Jacob's cabin"?, I bet that was to keep Killer at bay. Maybe...still unsure about the details there with the cabin.
Furthermore, I think that Killer is some kind of god of death - hence why the "Smoke Monster" judges people for their actions in this life, takes the lives of some, and hence why he can invoke the images of the dead! So what kind of god does that make Jacob? So far by his opening comments it just seems like he likes "progress" and chaos.
And the Losties? I think they've been caught up in a giant game of chess as the two gods try to assert their power and influence over the group for their own pleasure and ends.
The "Hostiles"? I think - much like this new group toting Locke's body - they're devotees to the Jacob god. But then, does anybody worship and serve Killer? Hmmm....to every yin there is a yang.
Back in 1977 I think it's pretty clear that our Losties caused the "Incident", as they were always meant to. And I assume that is what will vault them into modern day...but I'm guessing they'll still be on the Island with nothing erased. I'm just wondering if Dr. Chang will be transported with him as the electromagnetism vaults them through time. If not, then how on earth does he survive a nuclear blast?
Soooo many questions, sooo many months until the next season. Superb finale. A+++ all the way!
Helpful Answer?
(8)
(0)
Helpful: csandoval, jasoncalacanis, rslakinski, lon, robbrown, jeffhoard, marcand, cynthiag
Tip gno for this answerOther Answers (9)
May 14, 2009 07:27 AM
We seem to be filling in the Egyptian pantheon: Jacob = Sobek (check the alligator head and this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobek)
Richard Alpert = Ra
Horace Goodspeed = Horus
Locke = ? Going to guess Osiris
Sobek, Ra and Horus also seem to have a lot of dealings in Egyptian mythos, so they seem to 'fit' well together.
Beyond that ... not sure.
I wasn't happy with it. Not a lot happened for two hours except a few hippie gunfights (again). This season has been really strong, so the weak finale was a surprise -- I expected more.
Source(s):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobek
Tags: sobek, horus, lost
Helpful Answer?
(3)
(0)
Helpful: tracebooks, lon, robbrown
Tip markjeffrey for this answer
May 14, 2009 01:17 PM
I noticed that. But I bet that the creators have not got it completely paralleled down to a straight Egyptian pantheon story, because then we could predict it more easily.
Nice for a pop culture hit to be mixing in some real culture though!
Report
Nice for a pop culture hit to be mixing in some real culture though!
May 14, 2009 06:40 PM
Wow, I'm supirsed that you didn't like it. I just finished it and thought that it was great.
The continuing gun battle was a little drawn out, however I think that it served the "action" component of the story and also motivated the characters to make the decisions that they did. Juliette's back-and-froth path was especially effected by the battle and the explosion will of course lead the story into the next season.
All-in-all, you've called the Egyptian mythology influence. I agree that the characters are unfolding against the characters that have already been introduced by myths.
Report
The continuing gun battle was a little drawn out, however I think that it served the "action" component of the story and also motivated the characters to make the decisions that they did. Juliette's back-and-froth path was especially effected by the battle and the explosion will of course lead the story into the next season.
All-in-all, you've called the Egyptian mythology influence. I agree that the characters are unfolding against the characters that have already been introduced by myths.
May 14, 2009 09:45 AM
I loved it. What really surprises me about this series is how Josh Holloway and Terry Quinn have stolen the show. I thought that the characters of Jack and Kate would carry this show, but it is Sawyer and Locke who have captivated me, and Holloways performance in this episode was incredible.
Sawyer for all his toughness is, in reality, at the mercy of the the others around him. You see this in the expression of bewilderment on his face at the actions of Jack, Kate and Juliet. He is buffeted by their changing attitudes and plans. Although he teases Hugo, he actually feels more at ease in the company of the big guy.
For Sawyer, destiny is a lot less comfortable than normalcy.
The real mystery is John Locke. The man that looks like John Locke appears to be the man that was on the island at the beginning with Jacob.
And so we have wheels within wheels. The conflict between Ben and Charles Widmore is secondary to the real conflict between Jacob and the other guy.
Permalink | Report
May 14, 2009 03:18 PM
Ok, here's what I've been thinking, after looking into this a bit. The Island has long been a character in and of itself. In many cultures, the Earth itself is envisioned as an island (sometimes on the back of a turtle, or another creature).
In ancient Egypt, Nit (Nieth) was the creator of all life, and the protector of Pharoah, Ra, and the god/ddess (s/he was androngenous) to whom the other gods came when they could not settle their disputes. She also guarded the coffin and associated canopic jars of one of the sons of Horus. S/he was the patron goddess of both war--and weaving. I am looking at her hieroglyphs for her name, and I think they may have been either on the wall in the underground area where the bomb was, or was on Jacob's weaving.
Isn't this what he was making?
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bd/Egypt.Papyrus.01.jpg
That would be Anubis.
Ammit is another crocodile-headed god, whose job it was to judge the hearts of the dead. She was known as Devourer of Souls, but her function was to destroy evil. She was the guardian of the lake of fire. I'm thinking she's the smoke thing. I don't mean "Ammit is the smoke thing", but that somehow we'll find out that this is all Egyptian legend become real.
How that could happen is this: we know the Island can become shaken free of time and space. Perhaps at one time in the past, the island was in the Mediterranean, or off the coast of the Arabian Peninsula in the Arabian Sea.
According to Egyptian myth, at one point Osiris was killed and washed up on the banks of the Nile. What if he washed up on the banks of the Island instead?
According to the myth, then he was reanimated as Lord of the Dead.
I think Richard is Osiris in some way. Osiris was called "Ever Youthful", which we've noticed about Jacob; but it applies to both of them.
Then the rest makes sense: Horus, his son, was charged with protecting the people from Set, who killed Osiris and is thus both his enemy and Horus'. Set, incidentally, was Osiris' older brother, and the god of storms, darkness, and *necessary* chaos.
Horus would be Jacob. The legend also says that sometimes he would fail to recognize friends and mistake them for enemies, during the dark phase of the moon.
In the legend, Set and Horus had battles for years, so maybe I've got Osiris and Horus switched. But from last night's episode (the final episode of the season) this is a battle that's been raging for centuries, and this might finally be the last one.
There's an interesting little story about keeping a body in a box, too, when Set either tricked or put Osiris into a lead box that became his coffin. Only according to last night's episode and my reading of this, that would have been Set in the box.
Daniel Faraday's mother could possibly be Nephthys, sister/wife of Set, whose role it was to both guard Horus, and a very important role that included "gathering and mourning"--a mystical cycle crucial to the balance of chaos and order. She ages, though. So I'm not sure about this one, but it's a good parallel. Together with Juliet, they accomplished this season's goal. In the legend, it was Isis and Nephthys together who did the gathering and mourning.
So I think the background myth is from the whole Egyptian Underworld myth, and doesn't have much to do with other Egyptian gods like Ra.
I don't think that it's a straight retelling of the Egyptian religious myths, but a story that focuses on one of them and then brings other things in. Juliet, for example, has a lot in common with Isis. But she's not Isis: we know her parents divorced when she was around 10; that her sister had trouble conceiving. She ages. Daniel Faraday's mother ages.
So, I guess the series could be construed as: Part of the Egyptian pantheon were real (the ones associated with death). They are on a time-traveling island that appears on no charts. They handpick people to prove their respective points of good over evil/evil over good. The Oceanic Flight were hand-picked for the final battle, and it appears some of them were in the process of squaring off against each other. Only pairs of opposites like Bernard and Rose find peace; Kate/Jack/Sawyer/Juliet need to figure out which of them are going to pair off to find their place in the battle. Looks like they did in this episode; or maybe they got it wrong and that's why Juliet ended up at the bottom of the unbuilt hatch.
Next season? "They're coming" might refer to everyone coming back to life because the hatch was never built; it might refer to others in the Pantheon coming back to settle things. Hard to say.
Source(s):
http://www.touregypt.net/featurestories/nit.htm
http://ablemedia.com/ctcweb/consortium/ancientegyptiangodsneith.html
http://www.ancientegyptonline.co.uk/thegods.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duat
Tags: ancientegypt, lost, theories
Helpful Answer?
(2)
(0)
Helpful: rslakinski, lon
Tip tracebooks for this answerVoted as best: easyeboy
May 14, 2009 03:41 PM
I might be very, very wrong about this - but I'm a little hesitant to jump into literal examination of Egyptian lore. I'd definitely call it an influence - even a presence (what with the statue and hieroglyphics and all. But I think trying to fit Lost into the exact Egyptian mythology is like trying to cram a square peg into a round hole. Or when I try to jam to puzzle pieces together that I'm sure "must" fit...even though they don't.
I might eat my words a year from now.
Report
I might eat my words a year from now.
May 14, 2009 04:01 PM
Please note, I said "I don't think that it's a straight retelling of the Egyptian religious myths, but a story that focuses on one of them and then brings other things in. " That was a couple of paragraphs from the bottom (I know it was a long post, but then, it's a long series).
And I'm not trying to fit it into the mythology exactly, but there are specific things about specific gods that fit specific characters and their interactions with each other, and I find that *very* interesting.
Report
And I'm not trying to fit it into the mythology exactly, but there are specific things about specific gods that fit specific characters and their interactions with each other, and I find that *very* interesting.
May 14, 2009 09:42 PM
Well, there's definitely stuff going on with Egyptian mythology...The presence of the Sobek statue and all the hieroglyphics (not to mention a character NAMED Horace/Horus) confirm that. But that opening scene also reminded me of the opening of Shakespeare's "The Tempest." A "magician" of sorts, trapped on an island in exile, uses his powers to "call" on a ship. The castaways are then divided up into groups. Plots to overthrow Prospero are devised and abandoned, various other subplots are raised and thwarted, but all the time, Prospero is quiety influencing the main action and drawing the characters closer to him.
Similarly, "Jacob" is stranded on this island and manipulating those who pass through, though he's also locked in something of a rivalry with another god-like creature there.
Each season on "Lost" has set up this sort of binary conflict. We always think we're figuring out what the REAL rivalry is that's going on, only to find that it's more complex and mysterious than we thought...
Castaways vs. each other (Season 1)
Castaways vs. castaways from other side of the plane (Season 2)
Castaways vs. The Others (Season 3)
The Others vs. Dharma/Ben vs. Widmore (Season 4)
Jacob vs. Other God-like Being (Season 5)
My guess is Season 6 will continue this pattern...
Possibly:
Castaways vs. Other God-like Being (who's currently in possession of Locke's body, and probably has the ability to invade other dead people's bodies as well)
All the mention of some dark force that's "coming" could also be the final rivalry that we'll see play out, and even this playful back-and-forth among the gods is not the REAL FIGHT that's been playing out all this time. Perhaps Jacob and his rival are merely jockeying for position in preparation for some EVEN LARGER and more dangerous adversary that's still unknown to viewers.
Permalink | Report
May 14, 2009 09:44 PM
All the Egyptian stuff is mostly details...how the presence of other worldly beings was interpreted by early people's. When it comes to the origin of the electromagnetic energy, the context of much of the context of Jacob's conversation with the other guy in the flashback, as well as Richard Alpert's long life and familiarity (though not by sight) with those folks who brought the crate with Locke's body to him....
Seems to me the explanation that makes the most sense is that a group of extraterrestrials crashed a very long time ago and there is no longer any surface indication of their craft on the island. That they're ship included a "black smoke" security system that attacks those of unclear motives who get too close to the ship or are potentially in conflict with the ETs.
Indigenous people's built temple's and worshiped them while the ETs have continuously brought groups of other humans to the island to demonstrate their "worthiness" and ability to exercise their choice and free will ...and this goes towards the ET's purpose.
There is a faction within the ETs that does not believe in human's potential and is tasked with exposing this weakness.
The extraterrestrial's, while very powerful and beyond human abilities, are not gods but able to inhabit human forms for their purposes, extending those human form's lives indefinitely, and or granting other humans healing or other abilities.
The extraterrestrials include Richard Alpert, Jacob, the other guy he was speaking with in the flashback, and likely all those who recently arrived carrying Locke's cargo crate to show Richard.
The Dharma construction breached a reactor of some sort, and the large Wheel that Ben turned was some part of a control to manage a time dilation field inherent in the ship's construction.
AND, the detonation of a nuclear device may not reset the time line of events as Faraday and Jack believe....depending on what fuels the drive for the extraterrestrial craft...anti matter? some much heavier radioactive isotope? a nuclear detonation may do a number of things including further scramble events and time lines, obliterate the planet, or provide the extraterrestrials with the evidence of human free will they may have been seeking provoking the arrival of a mothership for their return or to retrieve those few humans responsible for a greater mission.
Permalink | Report
May 14, 2009 10:05 PM
I loved the finale! It further confirmed why Lost is my favorite show. I love what they did with Jacob, integrating him into the characters back stories, but I'm still wondering why he was there. Some had a point, like his meeting with Hurley, but others, like his meeting with Jack seemed insignificant.
I was shocked to fin out Locke was actually dead ever since Ben killed him. And it looks like the new Ben was that other guy in the form of a shape shifter. At least that's what I gathered. Ahh, now I gotta go back an rewatch it from that perspective.
I like that they answered a lot of questions, but like always, that bring up many more questions. So Jacob can live long like Richard and cannot be killed by that other guy, but Ben can kill him with a knife? I thought that was odd.
And now it looks like Juliet just detonated the H Bomb. Who know what kind of effect that will have.
Overall, awesome finale. The producers, writers, and actors of this show are amazing. Can't wait til next season!
Permalink | Report
May 14, 2009 10:15 PM
Just some reflections: Black vs white. Good vs Evil. Faith vs Science. We continue to get this play of opposing forces throughout the story. Two mysterious men (Jacob and "Esau") - dressed in black and white discuss what sounds like some cosmic battle, some pattern, some endless loop they've been playing out through the ages. Are they demigods? Fallen angles? Or are they ordinary men - somehow caught up and displaced from the normal flow of time, space and physical laws by the island - doomed to relive a gruesome series of wars and battles that take place throughout the ages over control of the island? Could they have been soldiers or researchers from the US Army mission that once visited the island? They certainly seem to have some modern sensibilities despite their appearance hundreds of years ago watching as the Black Rock comes to the island.
The men speak of the endless violence - everyone comes to the island to kill one another and fight for control, and it always ends the same. But in the finale we are presented with an alternative - Rose and Bernard. They have simply chosen to live in peace and harmony. And they have been allowed to do so. Rose and Bernard are appearing more and more like the "Adam and Eve" found in the cave in season 1. Perhaps they are the only ones who come to realize that the island need not be a place of fear and death - it can be Eden - it is a matter of ones own choosing.
But the two men, they cannot seem to find peace. Must one of them die in order to break the holding pattern they find themselves in? We know that Jacob can leave the island, but can he ever be free of it? Is he like Jack, doomed and compelled to always return? And now that Jacob appears dead - now that the closing title has flipped from white on black to black on white - the power of the island has changed hands? Jacob, who we were lead to believe was the malevolent force, was depicted as a compassionate figure in this episode - weaving his way through the lives of the Losties - tugging at the threads like those in a loom in order to create a new pattern as he worked to help each one of them
Now that Jacob appears slain by the real force that has haunted the Losties from day one. The question is, who are "they" and how will they stop him?
Permalink | Report
May 14, 2009 11:10 PM
OMG the episode last night was totally awesome!!!! Well I couldn't sleep last night and I began to think of what might be the results of what was shown. I think the Miles may have been right. What they did by letting Jack put the bomb into the hatch may have been the reason of them being there in the first place. Miles' father got his hand injured and that could've cause him to have had his hand lost in the first place. I believe that things will still be the way they are even if Juliet were to have the bomb to explode. I think that the whole loop thing has been going on for awhile and maybe Jacob and the other character with him having been living life over and over again and have been trying to fix things ever since, that's why jacob has been trying to get things tied up together with getting everyone on the island to the points where they are suppose to be to that very moment. I'm pretty sure that they couldn't have fixed it because they still have one more season to go through. So, this may start all over again but with a few changes. Pieces of the puzzle with Jacob meeting everyone will finally be explained. But i believe that they are either going to forget one other which was their plan in the first place by setting off that bomb but somehow still have some memories of each other but vaguely. It'll be like a Donnie Darko ending. Or they will still be living out their lives on the island and continue their journey.
Permalink | Report
May 16, 2009 10:17 PM
I'll comment on the Jacob / Esau conflict and how Locke and Ben play a part. There are a lot of good comments already on other aspects. From the argument that Jacob and Esau are having at the beginning of the episode, it appears that Jacob keeps bringing people to the island to try and work something out. Bringing the Black Rock to the island was just one moment in a long history. Esau believes it will never work and is looking for a loophole to kill Jacob.
Now we see Jacob interacting with the Losties before they ever come to the island. He is careful to touch each one of them and must be selecting them to come somehow.
Esau has been looking for his loophole and he has found it by taking on the appearance of dead people in order to manipulate those on the island. Jack's father, Christian, and now Locke. Richard thinks that "Esau in the guise of Locke" is the real leader, but actually that role has fallen back on Ben after the real Locke's death.
When they approach the statue, Richard complains that only the leader can come into Jacob's home, thinking that only Esau/Locke can come in. But Ben is the leader again and he is able to come in. Esau/Locke has manipulated Ben, the leader of the Others, to want to kill Jacob. This is the loophole - Ben doesn't realize that he is the real "Leader" and comes in to see Jacob because the rules allow him too and then stabs Jacob in an attempt to kill him.
Somehow, I think that despite the loophole that Esau has found, Jacob will not die from Ben's stabbing.
Permalink | Report
Answer this Question
Related Questions
Do you think that Thanksgiving has lost its original meaning?
Do you think that the Yankees will win the World Series again next season?
Have you seen the original Prisoner series starring Patrick McGoohan? If so, here's y...
I would like to open my first checking account, which banking company would you recom...
Do you think that the Yankees will win the World Series again next season?
Have you seen the original Prisoner series starring Patrick McGoohan? If so, here's y...
I would like to open my first checking account, which banking company would you recom...
Ask a Question
Buy Mahalo Dollars with Credit Card or PayPal
Top Members
Most Popular Tags
Categories
- Anonymous
- Arts & Design
- Beauty & Style
- Books & Authors
- Business
- Cars & Transportation
- Consumer Electronics
- Coupons Deals
- Education
- Entertainment
- Environment
- Fitness
- Food & Drink
- From Email
- From Iphone
- From Twitter
- Health
- History
- Hobbies
- Home & Garden
- How Tos
- Humor
- Jobs
- Legal
- Local
- Love & Relationships
- Mahalo Answers Community
- Money
- Music
- News
- NSFW
- Parenting
- Pets
- Science & Mathematics
- Services
- Shopping
- Social Science
- Society & Culture
- Sports
- Technology & Internet
- Travel
- Video Games
Welcome New Members
Mahalo Dollars are the currency of Mahalo Answers.
Each Mahalo Dollar costs $1.
Once you earn more than 40 Mahalo Dollars, you can request to be paid via PayPal. Each Mahalo Dollar is currently worth $0.75 when paid out via PayPal. Learn More

It began in the opening scene of the season finale when Jacob and "Essau" (as people are calling him) made their bet.
For centuries people have been lured to the island for one reason or another. Most recently in the modern era, beginning with Richard. There is more to Richard than we know. Beginning with the invention of the nuclear or in this case, the Hydrogen bomb, we have two groups on the island; "The Others" lead by Faraday's mom and Charles Widmore and "The Dharma Initiative". These two groups are opposing forces. We can debate why they are there and what each group's goal or mission is. I think we learn what their mission is ultimately in this episode. The Other's are there to stop the Dharma Initiative's Swan program. I still do not understand what the purpose of the Swan or The Hatch is.
Here is where it gets good.
In the last episode, we discover Jacob has hand picked or recruited John Locke, Kate, Jim, Jack, Saide (sp) and the Japanese couple. Why? If he is the good power, what was his reason for recruiting the people he did? Was it to destroy the Swan? These are all selfish people and yet they all gave their lives for this purpose; destroying the Swan. On one side we have this team in 1977 working together in a very self-less way to destroy the Swan and in 2007 it only takes on selfish person, Ben, to kill Jacob.
Through the Swan, or man's attempt to harness the power of nature, man would have eventually destroyed itself. Through the Hydrogen bomb, man's own doomsday device, a group of self-less people from The Others, Dharma and the Oceanic Flight (many recruited by Jacob) may have destroyed the Swan.
So, in 2010, Jacob and "Essau" are sitting, alone on the island again waiting for the next groups of humans to play their little test of humanity, again. If life goes back to normal for the passengers of Oceanic, according to the time travel that has taken place so far, they should remember their journey's on the island. If this is true, and we are talking about Jack and Jacob's "destiny" then won't they all find their place in life? If, the Swan or the energy pocket is not discovered or was indeed destroyed in 1977 thereby wiping threat of it, there should not be a need for the Dharma initiative.
If there is no Dharma initiative, there is no need for The Others. So, the Others are not on the island.
However, both the Dharma and Others people will be out in the world, probably not going after each other.
So, why did the woman call Richard, "Richardus", thus making him sound Latin. Richard has to powerful of a role to overlook. It was Richard Locke went sought, it was Richard who knocked out Faraday's mom, it is Richard who does not seem to age and calling Richard by a ancient Latin sounding name and then using a secret code to confirm his identity? So, Jacob send her to find Locke's body and present it to Richard. Why? Why is Richard this important? Is he Jacob's semi-human keeper/protector? If he is, then it is Richard who is the real leader of The Others, right?
What part of this story will be told in 2010?
How will this journey of self-discovery change each of the main characters?
Who is Richard and what is his relationship with Jacob? Was he Jacob's first recruit? Have we learned his story, yet?
I hadn't considered the Swan to be such a critical point - but maybe you're right! Maybe I've underestimated the role of the Swan. You've given me some points to think about.