I have the Samsung BD-P3600 with Netflix streaming on it... and I'm done for all time! Thing is amazing for movies.... of course, if you want to download from the web it doesn't do that.
Permalink | Report

Dude - spend an extra $200 over Apple TV and get a Mac Mini. I got one for our 52" and am so glad I got that instead of an Apple TV. Looks awesome and is completely versatile.
Permalink | Report

ummm.....why don't you get TIVO desktop plus and use your TIVO to watch the video you download?
http://www.tivo.com/buytivo/tivogear/software/index.html

You can already watch Netflix Video on TIVO
http://www.tivo.com/whatistivo/on-demand/watch-netflix/index.html
or BlockBuster or Amazon, plus plenty of Video podcasts are already available.
http://www.tivo.com/whatistivo/on-demand/

With TIVO Desktop you can also view photo slideshows from your computer as well....

Why do you want to spend money on another box/service?
Permalink | Report

You've indicated that you already have a Tivo. If you indeed have a Tivo, and not a generic DVR you can already do everything you mentioned you want. With Tivo's Desktop software you can send files from your computer to the Tivo to watch. Also, you can now watch Netflix streaming on Tivo. You'll need a TivoHD or Series 3 to be able to to do this.
Permalink | Report

Modding an AppleTV for Boxee sounds like a great option, but it won't allow you to get the Netflix content. For that you'll have to use a Mac Mini with a DVI-> HDMI converter
Permalink | Report

AppleTV is my pick, I haven't put boxee on it since hulu is blocked in canada and that would be my prime reason for modding it. Otherwise the apple service has been pretty top notch. Also now that YouTube is going to stream 1080p it couldnt get much better.
Permalink | Report

I have an AppleTV and love it. I use HandBrake to rip DVDs to my Mac which I can add to my iTunes Library. I also use Toast to copy my TiVo recordings into my iTunes Library. I have hundreds of movies and hours and hours and hours of TV shows in iTunes that stream to the AppleTV.
Permalink | Report

Living in Canada, I have no access to the Roku yet, but having used both the Slingbox Pro, and the Apple TV, I recommend the Apple TV. I had non-stop problems getting the Slingbox to work at all, and if the house used Vonage service, just forget having a Slingbox period.
The Apple TV has not been a picnic mind you, but in it's latest software version, is working better than ever. Do not bother using wi-fi at all. You will want to bash the box in with a hammer when you experience how long a wireless connection takes. Get enough ethernet cable to run from your router to your TV, and if you have several devices (we have a PS3, XBox360, Apple TV, and a Wii) just buy a "switch" so they can all run off one cable. My boys were much happier once we stopped using wi-fi for the Xbox. The on-line games were more stable.
Now, add the Apple TV as a device in iTunes, (entering the code on the screen) and you will be ready to watch movies. Isn't that what this whole exercise was about?
Permalink | Report

I'm doing something in that direction for my house too. I'll be using a mac mini, which will have a shared folder over samba where I'll put all the movies and stuff I download in my others computers. I'm probably going to use Front Row with this plugin http://code.google.com/p/understudy/ that allows me to watch Hulu and Netflix on it. I don't know, I been evaluating several options for a while and a mac mini seems to be the best choice, a little expensive but really powerful.
Permalink | Report

I would get an XBOX 360, awesome gamemachine and "set-top" box all in one. Streaming video, netflix, facebook, last.fm.
Permalink | Report

Not sure if you can get use these in the US. We use them downunder. http://www.beyonwiz.com/ DP-S1 with LIDic.. The Digital TV in US is not the same I believe however this may help. We can record both free to air and cable onto the HDD.
Permalink | Report

I bought one of the new Mac Mini's and I stream everything off via Hulu and Netflicks streaming. Its hooked up to a nice LCD and 5.1 system (which works on some Netflicks streaming movies.

You can get an AppleTV mod for any mac, I got it from this guy: http://www.wiseontech.com/downloads

Here's how I hooked it up:

1. VIDEO
Mini --- Mini DVI to DVI --- DVI to HDMI --- LCD

2. AUDIO
Mini --- 3.5mm to RCA --- sound/reciever

- - -

Ultimately, if you're going to mod the AppleTV then I thin kthat's yoru best option, but I would just insure you can use Hulu. It could just be a personal love for Hulu though I guess. I love being able to use Pandora in my home from the 5.1 though- not sure how much importance you put on that though.
Permalink | Report