For a woman to tell you why she doesn't like you, she risks a difficult confrontation. Natural instinct says to smile at someone until you can get a safe distance away. The best way to get good feedback is to ask her friends. They know all the details and are less likely to feel threatened by sharing.
Permalink | Report

Someone who is breaking up with you faces several barriers to giving you honest feedback:
A) Everyone hates conflict, the real reason may be something you've fought over and she's decided to avoid.
B) A lot of people don't like to hurt someone's feelings. So most people try to find a reason that seems inoffensive.
C) Sometimes, if one person isn't accepting the break-up, the other has to avoid giving any reason that could be negotiated. "Oh, I can change that, let's get back together"
D) Any reason given may not be seen as the truth, anyway. If it's not what you want to hear, there's a good chance you'll challenge it.

Now, if you wait a couple years, and the break-up is no longer open to question, you might get the real reason.
Permalink | Report

Although i have no personal experience, me and my friends have sometimes philosophically tossed around the idea of making such an admission a positive thing.

For example - i'm not saying word it this way, it's just to outline the kind of message to send - "For next time when i date someone if i made any mistakes i don't want to make the same mistakes next time around, could you help me see where i might have done better/hurt you"
Then you gotta take it well, perhaps a bit somber/serious so as not to seem fake, but don't break visibly unless you know she/he is just being cruel for being cruel, they gotta know that hurts you.

Although that IS a flawed tactic, if it's simple incompatibility that won't work so well, it's perhaps better to ask friends AFTER determining that's not creating gossip (a BIG no-no in the woman world, creating gossip out of a breakup, common (unfortunately) but UNfriendly)
Permalink | Report

If someone doesn't want to date you, it almost always means there is something about you that they don't find appealing or compatible. It feels rude to point those sorts of things out to someone, even if they are asking. Many decent humans (women, in particular) are socialized to believe that it is very rarely OK to tell someone things that would make him feel criticized or bad about himself. Also, people tend to get defensive in these situations and try to talk you out of what you think about them, which is annoying at best.

For example, let's say you ask me out and I don't want to date you because I find you boring (hypothetically of course). If you ask me why I won't go out with you and I say "Well, frankly, you seem nice enough but you tend to bore me." then that's just rude or even bitchy. For all I know, you'll go home and mope for weeks about the fact that I called you boring. Or, worse, spend 45 minutes trying to convince me that you're not boring at all--I have just not experienced your exciting side . . . .
So, instead, I just refuse your kind offer as politely as possible, trying my hardest not to be insulting.

Worse yet, maybe I don't want to date you for some reason you couldn't possibly change. For example, possibly you are too short for me to feel comfortable with you in social couple situations, or your face reminds me of my creepy great-uncle. What benefit would there be to my telling you that? You can't do anything about it.

In instances where you are turned down by someone you really think you would be good with, I recommend you politely accept their refusal and then take opportunities when you are in group social situations together not to impress her, but to be yourself--your real self. If, after getting to know the real you, she seems no more interested, resign yourself to be friends or acquaintances and keep your eyes open for someone who appreciates you for who you are.

If you truly want feedback on how to be a more appealing date, ask your trusted friends and family for feedback on changes you could make to be a better person. If you focus on improving yourself in general you will almost certainly make yourself more attractive to potential dates.
Permalink | Report