Hamptons Hotels

The Mahalo Top 7

1. Frommer's: The Hamptons Hotels
2. Fodor's: Hamptons & Montauk Hotels  
3. Concierge.com: The Hamptons Hotels and Lodging  
4. TripAdvisor: The Hamptons Hotel Reviews  
5. Official Tourism Site: Hamptons Lodging
6. LongIslandLodging.com: South Fork (Hamptons) Lodging
7. Yahoo! Travel: East Hamptons, Southampton and Montauk Hotels

Hamptons Luxury Hotels

• Sunset Beach (Shelter Island) Phone: 631-749-2001 Google Map
  • Concierge.com Recommendation   : "Each of the 20 rooms is decked out in mod furniture and white-on-white bedding and has a private terrace, complete with lounge chairs and a view of Crescent Beach and Shelter Island Sound."

• • Fodor's Review   : "Each retro-style guest room has a sundeck that looks out over the parking lot to the water."

• • Frommer's Exceptional Rating: "The minimalist rooms are done all in white, with contemporary aluminum lamps and splashes of color..."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• The Ram's Head Inn (Shelter Island) Phone: 631-749-0811 Google Map
  • Fodor's Choice   : "Rooms, furnished in a simple country style, are bright; they often book up months ahead of time."

• • Frommer's Very Highly Recommended: "[Y]ou don't come here to sit in your room; the grounds are gorgeous, with Adirondack chairs, hammocks, a small beach, and free use of the hotel's boats."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Mill House Inn (East Hampton) Phone: 631-324-9766 Google Map
  • Concierge.com Recommendation   : "The three suites in the recent addition behind the main house have fireplaces and bathrooms big enough to ride a bike in..."

• • Fodor's Review   : "Each room has a fireplace and private bathroom, but from there they diverge stylistically, with influences ranging from Asian to nautical to floral."

• • TripAdvisor 4.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Huntting Inn (East Hampton} Phone: 631-324-0410 Google Map
  • Concierge.com Recommendation   : "[O]ne of the best hotels in the Hamptons.

• • Fodor's Review   : "Each room is individually furnished with reproductions of 18th-century antiques."

• • TripAdvisor 4.0 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Maidstone Arms Inn   (East Hampton) Phone: 631-324-5006 Google Map
  • Concierge.com Recommendation   : "The 19 rooms and three cottages are handsomely decorated and furnished with local antiques..."

• • Fodor's Review   : "The front porch has wicker rocking chairs, and the garden in back is filled with rhododendrons. Antiques furnish the comfortable, individually decorated rooms."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

Hamptons Moderate Hotels

• 1708 House (Southampton) Phone: 631-287-1708 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "Some rooms are elegantly rustic; others are simply elegant."

• • Frommer's Exceptional Rating: "This cozy Colonial actually does date from 1708 and you can stay in the original 18th-century rooms."

• • TripAdvisor 4.0 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Olde Country Inn (Shelter Island) Phone: 631-749-1633 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "Privacy and romance are yours at this Victorian inn on a country lane."

• • Frommer's Exceptional Rating: "Guest rooms are outfitted with wrought-iron beds in formal antiques-filled surroundings."

• • TripAdvisor 4.0 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Montauk Harborside (Montauk) Phone: 631-668-2511 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "The bright, clean, airy rooms at this hotel on the beach have their own terraces, and most have an ocean view."

• • Frommer's Recommended: "A solid, affordable option that's just 3 blocks from the sound and one of its beaches, this small L-shaped motel offers decent rooms in a quiet locale."

• • TripAdvisor 4.0 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• East Deck Family Resort (Montauk) Phone: 631-668-2334 Google Map
  • Concierge.com Recommendation   : "This is definitely a no-frills, un-Hamptons experience: There are no high-thread-count sheets, Kiehl's soaps, or any shampoo at all, for that matter -- just simple motel accommodations."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

Hamptons Affordable Hotels

• Sunrise Guest House (Montauk) Phone: 631-668-7286 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "Rooms have hardwood floors and are done in soft vintage-floral prints."

• • TripAdvisor 4.0 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Culloden House Motel (Montauk) Phone: 631-668-9293 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "The modern accommodations at this motel, a three-minute walk from famous Gosman's Dock and the Harbor area, are sparkling clean and reasonably priced."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)

• Chequit Inn (Shelter Island) Phone: 631-749-0018 Google Map
  • Fodor's Review   : "Guest rooms, furnished sparingly with country antiques and reproductions, are bright and comfortable."

• • TripAdvisor 3.5 Rating   (Note: Community rating; may change)